比較

AI 自動化工具比較:n8n、Zapier、Make 與可自架的替代方案

比較 n8n、Zapier、Make、Power Automate、Activepieces、Windmill、Node-RED 與 Dify 的計費方式、能否自架與授權。2026 年 10 月更新。

本頁內文目前為英文版,中文翻譯準備中。

Who this page is for

This page is for anyone who has hit the limits of a free Zapier or Make plan, been surprised by an automation bill, or been told to "just self-host n8n" and wants to know what that involves. It covers the tools people actually shortlist: the big no-code connectors (Zapier, Make, Microsoft Power Automate), the self-hostable workflow builders (n8n, Activepieces, Windmill, Node-RED), and Dify, which is built for LLM apps and agents more than app-to-app plumbing.

We don't rank these tools with a single score, because the right answer depends on three things a score hides: what the vendor counts as one billable unit, whether you can or want to run the software yourself, and what the license allows once you build something commercial on top of it. The table lists those facts for each tool, with links to the official source. The scenarios further down turn them into a recommendation.

How to choose

  1. Find the billing unit. Zapier bills a task for each successful action step. Make bills credits, and most module actions cost one. n8n bills one execution per full workflow run, however many steps it has. A 10-step workflow that runs 1,000 times a month is about 10,000 Zapier tasks or Make credits, but 1,000 n8n executions.
  2. Decide who runs the servers. Self-hosting (n8n Community, Activepieces, Windmill, Node-RED, Dify Community) removes per-run fees, but you take on updates, backups, uptime, and security.
  3. Read the license, not the badge. "Open source" ranges from Apache-2.0 (Node-RED) and MIT core (Activepieces) to AGPLv3 (Windmill) and source-available terms (n8n's Sustainable Use License, Dify's modified Apache-2.0). This matters if you resell or embed the tool.
  4. Check the connectors you need. Make sure your must-have apps have native connectors and that the triggers you need exist. Every tool on this list can call a generic HTTP API, but native triggers save the most time.
  5. Count AI usage separately. AI steps often cost more than a normal step, or need your own API key. Look at how each tool meters LLM calls before you build agent-style flows.
  6. Plan for team features. SSO, audit logs, Git-based versioning, and shared credentials are usually on the higher tiers.

Comparison table

ToolBest forLicense / pricing modelSelf-hostOfficial URL
n8n Technical teams who want complex workflows and the option to self-host Sustainable Use License (source-available, not OSI). Cloud from €20/mo billed annually (Starter); billed per workflow execution Yes (Community Edition) n8n.io
Zapier Non-technical users who need the biggest app catalog fast Proprietary SaaS. Free 100 tasks/mo; Professional from $19.99/mo billed annually (750 tasks) No zapier.com
Make Visual, branching scenarios at a lower entry price Proprietary SaaS. Free 1,000 credits/mo; Core from $9/mo billed annually ($10.59 monthly; 10,000 credits) No make.com
Microsoft Power Automate Companies already on Microsoft 365, plus desktop RPA Proprietary. Standard connectors are included with many Microsoft 365 licenses; Premium $15/user/mo paid yearly No (cloud; desktop flows run on your Windows PCs) microsoft.com/power-platform/products/power-automate
Activepieces A simpler, MIT-licensed n8n alternative with AI steps MIT core + commercial EE folder. Cloud Free 1,000 credits/mo; Plus $20/mo Yes activepieces.com
Windmill Developers turning Python/TypeScript scripts into workflows and internal apps AGPLv3 core + proprietary enterprise features. Community Edition free; Enterprise from $120/mo Yes windmill.dev
Node-RED IoT, home automation, and event-driven flows on small hardware Apache-2.0, free Yes (laptop, Raspberry Pi, Docker, cloud) nodered.org
Dify Building LLM chatbots, RAG apps, and agent workflows Modified Apache-2.0 (no multi-tenant SaaS or logo removal without a commercial license). Cloud Sandbox free; Professional $590/workspace/yr Yes (Community) dify.ai

Notes on each tool

n8n: You pay per full workflow run, so large multi-step workflows are much cheaper than on step-billed tools. The Community Edition is free to self-host, but the Sustainable Use License is not an OSI open-source license. Read it before you offer n8n to customers as a service.

Zapier: The fastest way for a non-developer to connect two SaaS apps, and its catalog of 9,000+ apps is the largest here. The free plan only allows two-step Zaps. Every successful action step uses a task, so bills grow quickly with multi-step workflows.

Make: The visual scenario builder handles routers, iterators, and error handlers better than most no-code tools, and its entry price is low. Credits are counted per module action, so loops over large lists can use up a plan fast.

Microsoft Power Automate: If your company already pays for Microsoft 365, cloud flows with standard connectors may cost nothing extra. Premium connectors and attended desktop RPA need a Premium license, and the licensing rules are complex enough that you should check them with your admin.

Activepieces: Its core is MIT-licensed, so it's the most permissive self-hosted option in this group that still feels like a no-code tool. Its connector library is smaller than Zapier's or Make's, so check your apps first.

Windmill: Aimed at engineers. You write scripts in Python, TypeScript, Go, SQL and other languages, and Windmill handles scheduling, retries, permissions, and UIs. Self-hosting gives unlimited executions under AGPLv3, but SSO is capped at 10 users on the free edition.

Node-RED: A mature, fully Apache-2.0 flow editor with a big community node library, popular in industrial and smart-home setups. It has no hosted SaaS plan of its own and no AI features built in, though community nodes can add them.

Dify: The best fit here when the "workflow" is really an LLM app: chat, RAG over your documents, or a tool-calling agent. It isn't trying to replace Zapier for syncing CRM rows. The self-hosted license forbids running it as a multi-tenant service without a commercial agreement.

Which should you pick?

  • “I'm not technical and need Gmail → Sheets → Slack working today.” Start with Zapier, or Make if you expect branching logic and want a cheaper entry tier.
  • “Our Zapier bill keeps climbing with multi-step workflows.” Price the same workload in n8n executions. If you have someone who can run Docker, self-hosted n8n or Activepieces removes per-run fees.
  • “We're a Microsoft 365 shop.” Check what your current license already includes in Power Automate before you buy anything else.
  • “I need a permissive license because I'm embedding automation in my product.” Look at Activepieces (MIT core) or Node-RED (Apache-2.0) first, and avoid building on source-available terms without legal review.
  • “Our engineers want code, Git, and real tests.” Windmill, or n8n with code nodes.
  • “We want an internal AI assistant over company documents.” Dify, possibly triggered from n8n or Zapier.

FAQ

Is n8n really free?
The self-hosted Community Edition costs nothing to download and run under the Sustainable Use License. You still pay for your own server. n8n Cloud and the Business/Enterprise features are paid.
What is the cheapest Zapier alternative?
At list price, Make's Core plan ($9/mo billed annually, $10.59 monthly, for 10,000 credits) is lower than Zapier Professional ($19.99/mo billed annually for 750 tasks). Self-hosting n8n, Activepieces, Windmill, or Node-RED removes per-run fees entirely, but you take on hosting costs and maintenance.
What's the difference between a Zapier task, a Make credit, and an n8n execution?
A Zapier task is one successful action step. A Make credit is roughly one module action. An n8n execution is one complete run of a workflow, whatever its length. That's why the same workflow can cost very different amounts on each platform.
Can I self-host Zapier or Make?
No. Both are cloud-only services. If self-hosting is a requirement, look at n8n, Activepieces, Windmill, Node-RED, or Dify.

More on YunoDB

← 返回 AI 自動化工具 相關比較: 程式開發代理比較:價格與適用情境 · RAG 工具比較:價格與授權 · LLM 聊天工具價格比較 · 在自己電腦上跑 AI 模型:開源工具比較(Ollama、LM Studio、llama.cpp 等)